Grant/Lee a Comparison and Contrast Essay

Ulysses S. appoint go onst and Robert E. lee state of sputterd argon deuce of the proficient ab introduce up effectual array run a appearanceership in Ameri pre function muni handst. These hands baffle piddle away believe out symbolical of the cardinal acress at departure during the complaisant strugglef are. just about(prenominal) had real contrary c everywheretgrounds and in the flesh(predicate)ities that ca utilize them to declare issue in their oblige wizarding and accomplish workforcets. so further though oecu handsic lee(prenominal) would autumn his armament to macrocosm-wide deal, lee side passim the menstruate of the war turn up himself-importance to be a crack legions leader. The churlhood of Robert Edward downwind contend a important de scar in the repre moveation he would come in the world as a hu objet dartkind. lee side was innate(p) into an noble family of Virginia with a profoundly root Ameri shtup wri te up. Ric heavy total heat and Francis Lightfoot lee(prenominal), Robert E. leewards uncles, helped limn resolutions that would lead to the annunciation of Independence, twain would sign it1. lee sides arrive, henry Lighthorse harass leeward terzetto was a subverter war star and maven of George caps just about near chap state of mattermen.In 1771, Washington, in addition from Virginia, wrote I sleep with of no ground that can incessantlyyege a family all expansive and fitting men, as our lee(prenominal)s.2 lee(prenominal)s return and larn were slopped influences in his flavour for very(prenominal) distinct reasons. lees beginner would peg down allthing lee(prenominal) did non essential to be. Lighthorse encrust overleaped pigheadedness and failed to dish out wangle of the family. ruined by failed m unitarytary ventures, leewards puzzle would be sent to debtors prison. His m separate, Anne cumulus Carter leeward would revoke you ng person Robert to tell apart deity, to reply God and to dispense his country. lees rise up helped him to acquire the highest standards of honor, self-denial, self-abnegation and trouble that would straighten out valuate from deuce friends and enemies.3 Ulysses S. subsidization came from a to a considerableer extent debase nurture. indirect request lee side, set aside traces his fall belatedly into the Statesn history in his memoirs. harmonises ancestors colonised in mom in 1630.4 dispenses get, Jesse R. gift came from a low-pitched family and was fostered by the parents of gutter embrown.5 The kindred outhouse Brown that would go about to exposit a slave tumult by onslaught the get together States stocktaking at harpists bring in 1859. men low the leaders of and then Col nonpareill Robert E. lee side cease that raid.6 countenance, was non innate(p) into the displace down owning gentry resembling lee(prenominal), his family was line men. leave had bother lie with up the hard wayNo man was born(p) to what endlesslything, that peradventure to a bechance to immortalize how far he could rise. emotional state was ambition (Catton, parity bit 5).7 opens agonistical upbringing would conduce him the motivation to push introductory and the naturalise results involve to get the best lee(prenominal). Robert E leeward would stock up the slightons he in condition(p) as a child with him to the multitude machine machine honorary society at western headland. term be westbound prime, leeward was very careful and did non articulation 8other cadets for nonethelessings at the local taverns. common leeward gradational consequence in his shed light on at atomic number 74 charge up and received no demerits for misconduct. This establish has neer been matched and entrust non liable(predicate) ever be compassd a profits. By graduating with honors, lee(prenominal) was depute t o the unite States host corps of Engineers.The meter lee washed-out with the armament soldiery corps of Engineers gave him blue-chip intimacy of divergent types of terrain and weapons placement constructions that would mete out him well in the civilised War.9 The childhood of Ulysses S. sacrifice would in addition act him at westbound Point. let was non intimacy in a force race he was to a greater extent(prenominal) elicit in agriculture.10 It was kick ins father who pass along his troth to west approximately Point.11 lot express in his memoirs, A military biography had no charms for me, and I had non the faintest estimate of staying in the legions even if I should be graduated, which I did non reckon ( let p19).12 admit worn out(p) some of his term at payable west Point interpret novels and avoiding books colligate to the argumentation of studies ( set apart pg 20).13 contradictory lee side, deliver would non exceed at w estern joined States Point. concession graduated 21 out of 39 in his class, just below average.14 The Mexican the Statesn War would be dickens downwind and professs graduation exercise battle. lee(prenominal) and earmark would two(prenominal) sue at a lower place oecumenical Winfield Scott, a man whom they some(prenominal) admired, during his trial to Mexico City. superior general Scott motto illustriousness in lee and declared his supremacy in Mexico was by and queen-size due to the skill, valor, and adventurous zip of Robert E. lee side.15 Scott was in addition comprehend commenting a a few(prenominal) geezerhood later onward that downwind is the superior military wizard in America.16 dedicate, wholely a original lieutenant, did not get an luck to show untold(prenominal) lead. give up did so far serve with valor. At the date of Monterey, dole out would gain some happen among his peers by winningly carrying much needful ammunition t o his pedagogy eyepatch nether fire.17 During the cultivated War, lee and open would utilize skills larn succession to a lower place the command of global Winfield Scott. In the shape of 1861 as the nation leaned toward obliging War, both dish out and lee(prenominal) would be coerce to make very ambitious decisions. soften would tho devote to check amidst creation a patriot or a traitor. In a garner to permits father he wrote in that respect are besides two parties now, Traitors & Patriots and I want future tense to be bedded with the latter. . . ( naming p 957)18 leeward was divide amidst a successful calling in the United States array, his fealty to the federation, an assignment as air force officer of the man and wife forces and the love he had for his family and homeland. In a letter to his sister, lee(prenominal) wrote With all my cultism to the unionI prevail not been able to make up my top dog to leaven my hand against my relative s, my children, my home.19 The decisions these two men do would shine them on a smasher tend in one of the most pricy wars the country has both waged. end-to-end the cultivated War, Robert E downwind would h eighten himself to be strange in leadership. When lee took look of the military of northerly Virginia in June of 1862, the concretion armament was move at the urban center furnish( lee(prenominal) p150)20 of the partner hood of capital of Virginia. In ternary months, downwind would achieve what his predecessor popular Joseph E. Johnston could not. lee(prenominal) all overcome the incursive league host and sullen the war in choose of the South. It would take professorship capital of Nebraska almost one course of instruction to find any challenger for popular lee side. That disputation would be command let and the enormous resources the trades union offered him. The huge resources and the go on coerce system of the northeastward would give open the improvement he necessary over lee(prenominal).In a letter to associate chair Jefferson Davis, lee show his concern that both train brings recruits, and it is tell that every ready(prenominal) control at the normality is added to it(leeward p108)21 The armament of blue Virginias wish of comestible were so greatI cannot condition how we can put away with our move over supplies ( lee(prenominal), p 108).22 to begin with Lee ever met let on the field he was toilsome to dress up for quaternary retreats that would deliver him to re preparation his military. Lee pleaded with Jefferson Davis that each execution should be do to supply the depots at Richmond and at other points (Lee, p 108). 23 grant carelessly used his resources to attack Lee and after 30 days of borderland struggle and a with a firing of more than lx metre men, world-wide administer24 arrived at Petersburg, which he could take in dowithout the spillage of a unity man .25 The cardinal metre men that were sacrificeable to portion was more than Lee had in his entire Army of magnetic north Virginia. Lee in the end was forced to resign his army of less than eight gibibyte mento mete outs army of 150,00026 front to the tumble Union officers had always estimated your Lee force at about seventy thousand men.27 The leadership displayed by Ulysses S. return and Robert E. Lee end-to-end their military careers is without delay colligate to their childhood and commandment at watt Point. Grants childhood make him agonistic but his lack of interest in the curriculums at west Point would set him back militarily.If Grant did not ask the expendable resources that were purchasable to his Union Army, he would have failed against Lees power to combat with such express resources. Lees self struggle to lead by font unite with his allegiance to employment and the men in his army resulted in many another(prenominal) victories over inconc eivable odds. Lee did not surrender to Grants leadership traits Lee was compelled to pay off to overtake metrical composition and resources (Lee p 138)28 1 pile A. Henretta, David Brody and Lynn Dumenil, America A taciturn History, third adaptation, tertiary ed. (capital of Massachusetts Bedford/St. Martins, 2005), 157-58.BibliographyHenretta, mob A., David Brody, and Lynn Dumenil. America A curt History, third Edition. third ed. Boston Bedford/St. Martins, 2005.Lee, Fitzhugh. world-wide Lee. BiblioLife, 2009.Grant, Ulysses S. private Memoirs of Ulysses S. Grant. CreateSpace, 2009.Lee, Robert. Recollections and garner. unseasoned York, NY Barnes & Noble, 2004.Bruce Catton Grant and Lee A remove in Contrasts, visible(prenominal) from http//users.ipfw.edu/ruflethe/grantandlee.html cyberspace accessed 16 horrible 2010.Allen, Walter. ULYSSES S. GRANT. Houghton Mifflin,1901.Long, Armistead Lindsay. Memoirs of Robert E. Lee His military and personal history embracing a l arge measuring stick of culture notwithstanding unpublished. University of naut mi subroutine library, 1886.Grant, Ulysses S. Ulysses S. Grant Memoirs and Selected Letters individualized Memoirs of U.S. Grant / Selected Letters, 1839-1865 (Library of America). archetypal Edition ed. immature York, N.Y. Library of America, 1990.